In our latest blogpost we review Too Good to be True (Harper Collins, 2025) by Prajakta Koli.
Too Good to Be True is a delightful debut by Prajakta Koli, a celebrated creator who brings her signature wit and charm into the world of fiction.
This Prajakta Koli book is already a bestseller and creating waves way before its release. Its also been a part of a controversy surrounding influencer publishing leading to a lot of online backlash for the publishers.
Controversy around the book
A social media user recently took to Instagram to voice their frustration with Prajakta Koli’s debut novel Too Good to Be True, but rather than focusing on the book itself, their discontent was aimed at HarperCollins, the renowned publishing house. The issue arose from the novel’s blurb, which the user felt mirrored the premise of Koli’s Netflix series Mismatched.
Watch the full video Here
This led to a discussion about the blurring of lines between Koli’s onscreen persona and her literary work, raising questions about originality and marketing strategies. While the blurb may have evoked comparisons, it remains to be seen how the book stands on its own merits in the world of fiction.
Innovative Marketing
Prajakta Koli, renowned as a content creator before branching out into acting, authorship, and climate activism, has taken an innovative step in the world of publishing by releasing an original soundtrack for her highly anticipated debut novel, Too Good To Be True.
In a move aimed at redefining book promotion, Koli’s soundtrack marks a groundbreaking moment in Indian publishing. It’s the first time that an original soundtrack and accompanying music video have been conceptualized and curated specifically for a romance novel, blending music with literature in an exciting and fresh way.
This bold initiative is set to create a new precedent for how books are promoted and experienced in India, offering fans and readers a multisensory connection to the story.
About the Book
From one of India’s most-loved creators comes something new to fall in love with.
Avani’s favourite thing to do is bury her nose in romance novels, but, honestly, life can’t be trusted to make the stories real, right?
But in the bookstore where she works, a man walks in, straight out of the pages of her favourite love stories. Aman is hot, successful, seems to know what she’s going to say before she’s said it, and just cannot get enough of her. In short, he’s perfect.
Then why is Avani losing her mind, ignoring the advice of her BFFs and trying to convince herself that he’s just too good to be true?
Will Aman ever be able to figure her out? And will Avani allow him to?
Wickedly witty, tender and utterly relatable at every turn, Too Good to Be True by Prajakta Koli is the sparkling, true-blue, will-they-won’t-they love story you’ve been waiting for!
This Prajakta Koli book revolves around Avani, a young woman who works in a bookstore and escapes into the dreamy world of romance novels. When Aman, a man seemingly straight out of her favorite stories, walks into her life, Avani must navigate the thrilling but perplexing emotions that follow.
Aman seems to tick all the boxes—charming, attentive, successful, and almost too good to be real. He embodies everything Avani has ever imagined in her fictional heroes, stepping straight out of the pages of her favorite romance novels. But as their relationship unfolds, Avani is plagued by doubts, unable to shake the feeling that perfection like his might just be a façade. Is Aman truly the ideal partner he seems, or is he simply too good to be true?
Our Thoughts
Prajakta Koli’s book Too Good to Be True masterfully navigates the delicate tension between fantasy and reality in modern relationships, skillfully blending humor with moments of profound self-reflection. Koli captures the whirlwind of emotions that come with falling for someone—those exciting bursts of infatuation, the exhilarating highs of connection, and the inevitable fears of vulnerability that follow. Through Avani’s experience, the book explores the nuanced journey of questioning one’s worth and desires, as well as the challenges of opening up to someone else without losing oneself in the process.
Koli’s portrayal of these emotions is refreshing, grounded in the relatable anxieties many young people experience in love. She highlights the delicate balance of authenticity—both in terms of how we present ourselves to others and how we come to understand and accept who we truly are. The narrative goes beyond the superficiality of a perfect love story, offering a rich exploration of self-doubt, growth, and the importance of being vulnerable with others without compromising one’s true identity.
In this way, the book is not just about romance but also about personal evolution—learning to trust oneself and embrace the imperfections of both love and life. By intertwining humor and heartfelt introspection, Prajakta Koli succeeds in portraying modern relationships as both exhilarating and complex, making this a story that feels emotionally real and accessible to readers.
With its seamless mix of romance and comedy, this Prajakta Koli book feels effortlessly contemporary and deeply relatable, resonating with readers who have ever dared to dream of a love story that feels too magical to be real.
Read more Book Reviews by Team KC
The narrative delves into the complexities and uncertainties of modern love, illustrating the delicate dance between fantasy and reality in relationships. Through Avani’s struggles and triumphs, Prajakta Koli weaves a compelling tale that underscores the importance of self-trust and self-awareness in navigating love. Avani’s journey is as much about understanding her own desires and insecurities as it is about finding romance, making her story one of growth, resilience, and self-discovery.
Koli skillfully balances humour, relatability, and emotional depth, creating a narrative that resonates deeply with young audiences who are navigating similar challenges in life and love. For readers accustomed to the intense emotional arcs and poignant storytelling of traditional romance authors like Nicholas Sparks, this debut may feel lighter in comparison. However, it is precisely this breezy tone, combined with authentic, engaging characters, that gives the book its unique charm.
Koli’s ability to capture the everyday quirks and dilemmas of contemporary relationships makes Too Good to Be True a delightful debut, offering a refreshing take on modern romance that will leave readers smiling and feeling seen.
Verdict: A fun and witty rom-com, Too Good to Be True is a promising start for a new author. This Prajakta Koli book is an ideal pick for young readers looking for a refreshing take on love and self-confidence.
About Prajakta Koli
Prajakta Koli, also known as MostlySane, is one of the most successful digital content creators in India, with over 17 million followers across social media platforms. As an actor, Prajakta is known for her lead role in Netflix India’s Mismatched and has starred in films such as Jug Jugg Jeeyo and Neeyat, and the upcoming Amazon Prime series, Andhera.
A passionate advocate for social causes, Prajakta serves on the advisory board for Goalkeepers by the Gates Foundation, has represented UNDP as its first Youth Climate Champion from India in global summits since 2021, advocating for climate action and sustainability, and representing young voices on global platforms, blending her entertainment success with social impact. She has also featured in Michelle Obama’s Daytime Emmy-winning docuseries promoting girls’ education. Too Good to Be True is her debut novel.
Prajakta lives in Thane, Maharashtra, and can be found on Instagram (@mostlysane), YouTube (MostlySane) and X (@imMostlySane).
Buy Prajakta Koli Book
Disclaimer: This page contains affiliate links.
Leave a Reply